---
title: "Meril Italy Srl and others v Edwards Lifesciences Corporation (UPC CoA 464/2024, 25-11-2025)"
description: "The Court of Appeal upheld EP 3 646 825 as amended by Auxiliary Request II and confirmed that Meril's Myval Octacor heart valve system infringes it."
url: https://pitch.law/academy/upc-court-of-appeal/upc-coa-464-2024-2025-11-25
lang: en
author: "UPC Case Law by Pitch"
editor: "Bart Lieben"
datePublished: 2026-11-18T10:07:28.153Z
dateModified: 2026-11-18T10:07:28.153Z
---

# Meril Italy Srl and others v Edwards Lifesciences Corporation

Decision of the UPC Court of Appeal of 25 November 2025, UPC CoA 464/2024.

UPC Case Law by Pitch, edited by [Bart Lieben](https://pitch.law/team/bart-lieben) · Published 18-11-2026

## TL;DR

The Court of Appeal upheld EP 3 646 825 as amended by Auxiliary Request II and confirmed that Meril's Myval Octacor heart valve system infringes it. The Court modified the injunction only to let XL valves reach patients for whom a physician confirms they are the only treatment option, and it cut the interim payment to €363,000. The decision sets out the UPC's own approach to inventive step, the default rule on permanent injunctions, and a 50% cap on interim awards of representation costs.

## Key holding

Inventive step under Art 56 EPC is assessed by identifying the objective problem, which must contain no pointer to the solution. The court then asks whether the skilled person, starting from any realistic starting point, would (not merely could) have arrived at the claimed solution, prompted by a pointer or as a matter of routine. Where infringement is found, the Court shall order a prohibition under Art 63(1) UPCA unless there are special reasons, such as disproportionality under Art 3 of the Enforcement Directive, and the interests of third parties such as patients may be weighed. As a general rule, Art 69(1) UPCA and R 150(2) RoP do not allow an interim reimbursement of more than 50% of the recoverable-costs ceiling.

## Questions decided

1. When are entities the "same parties" under Art 33(4) second sentence UPCA?
2. How far does the Court of Appeal review admission of subsequent patent amendments?
3. Can an embodiment in the specification fall outside the claims?
4. What is the UPC's approach to inventive step?
5. Can patient interests limit a permanent injunction and corrective measures?
6. What is the maximum interim award of representation costs?

## Case details

- Court: Court of Appeal of the Unified Patent Court, Panel 1
- Panel: Klaus Grabinski (President of the Court of Appeal); Peter Blok (legally qualified judge and judge-rapporteur); Emmanuel Gougé (legally qualified judge); Elisabetta Papa (technically qualified judge); Max Tilmann (technically qualified judge)
- Date: 25-11-2025
- Case number(s): UPC CoA 464/2024, UPC CoA 530/2024, UPC CoA 21/2025, UPC CoA 457/2024, UPC CoA 532/2024, UPC CoA 27/2025, UPC CoA 458/2024, UPC CoA 533/2024, UPC CFI 255/2023, UPC CFI 15/2023
- Parties: Meril Italy Srl (claimant in the direct revocation action); Meril GmbH and Meril Life Sciences Pvt Ltd. (defendants in the infringement action and counterclaimants for revocation); Edwards Lifesciences Corporation (claimant in the infringement action, defendant in the revocation proceedings). Each side was appellant in some appeals and respondent in others.
- Language of the proceedings: English
- Outcome: In the revocation, competence and claim-amendment appeals, all appeals are rejected.

## How to cite

Court of Appeal, Meril Italy Srl and others v Edwards Lifesciences Corporation, UPC CoA 464/2024, UPC CoA 530/2024, UPC CoA 21/2025, UPC CoA 457/2024, UPC CoA 532/2024, UPC CoA 27/2025, UPC CoA 458/2024, UPC CoA 533/2024, Decision of 25 November 2025 (OSCOLA)

## Full summary

Read the full analyses for free — create a free account: https://pitch.law/academy/upc-court-of-appeal/upc-coa-464-2024-2025-11-25

Topics: [Validity and revocation](https://pitch.law/academy/upc-court-of-appeal/topics/validity), [Costs and court fees](https://pitch.law/academy/upc-court-of-appeal/topics/costs-and-fees), [Suspensive effect and enforcement](https://pitch.law/academy/upc-court-of-appeal/topics/suspensive-effect-and-enforcement), [Procedure](https://pitch.law/academy/upc-court-of-appeal/topics/procedure)

## In the same case

- [Meril GmbH v Respondent 1 and SWAT Medical AB, UPC CoA 635/2024, 05-05-2025](https://pitch.law/academy/upc-court-of-appeal/upc-coa-635-2024-2025-05-05): The Court of Appeal set aside a Paris Central Division order that had given a European patent attorney and his company access to all pleadings and evidence in a revocation counterclaim.
- [Meril GmbH and others v Edwards Lifesciences Corporation, UPC CoA 166/2025, 18-04-2025](https://pitch.law/academy/upc-court-of-appeal/upc-coa-166-2025-2025-04-18): The Court of Appeal refused Meril's request to suspend the Munich Local Division's infringement decision in favour of Edwards Lifesciences pending Meril's appeal.
- [Meril Italy S.r.l. v SWAT Medical AB and another, UPC CoA 634/2024, 12-02-2025](https://pitch.law/academy/upc-court-of-appeal/upc-coa-634-2024-2025-02-12): A lawyer or European Patent Attorney who is personally a party before the UPC cannot represent themselves.
- [Meril GmbH v SWAT Medical AB and another, UPC CoA 635/2024, 12-02-2025](https://pitch.law/academy/upc-court-of-appeal/upc-coa-635-2024-2025-02-12): A lawyer or European Patent Attorney who is personally a party before the UPC must still be represented by someone else.
- [Meril Life Sciences Pvt. Ltd v Respondent 1 and SWAT Medical AB, UPC CoA 636/2024, 12-02-2025](https://pitch.law/academy/upc-court-of-appeal/upc-coa-636-2024-2025-02-12): A lawyer or European Patent Attorney who is a party before the UPC cannot represent himself and must instruct a separate authorised representative.

## More on validity and revocation

- [Netflix Services Germany GmbH and others v DivX, LLC, UPC CoA 176/2026, 02-11-2026](https://pitch.law/academy/upc-court-of-appeal/upc-coa-176-2026-2026-11-02): The Court of Appeal refused Netflix's request for suspensive effect against the Munich Local Division's infringement decision in favour of DivX, even though the EPO Opposition Division revoked the patent after that decision.
- [Appellant (name not stated) v Amycel, LLC, UPC CoA 935/2025, 02-11-2026](https://pitch.law/academy/upc-court-of-appeal/upc-coa-935-2025-2026-11-02): The Court of Appeal set aside a decision by default of The Hague Local Division and allowed the defendant's application to have it set aside under R 356 RoP.
- [Barco N.V. v Yealink (Xiamen) Network Technology Co., Ltd. and others, UPC CoA 145/2026, 16-10-2026](https://pitch.law/academy/upc-court-of-appeal/upc-coa-145-2026-2026-10-16): The Court of Appeal upheld the Brussels Local Division's refusal to let Barco add a late auxiliary request (AR6) whose claim 1 is identical to dependent claim 9, a claim neither asserted for infringement nor attacked in the counterclaim for revocation.
