---
title: "VMR Products LLC v NJOY Netherlands B.V. (UPC CoA 71/2025, 29-12-2025)"
description: "The Court of Appeal upheld the Paris Central Division's revocation of VMR Products' vaporizer patent EP 3 456 214 for lack of inventive step, rejecting all ten…"
url: https://pitch.law/academy/upc-court-of-appeal/upc-coa-71-2025-2025-12-29
lang: en
author: "UPC Case Law by Pitch"
editor: "Bart Lieben"
datePublished: 2026-11-18T10:07:28.153Z
dateModified: 2026-11-18T10:07:28.153Z
---

# VMR Products LLC v NJOY Netherlands B.V.

Decision of the UPC Court of Appeal of 29 December 2025, UPC CoA 71/2025.

UPC Case Law by Pitch, edited by [Bart Lieben](https://pitch.law/team/bart-lieben) · Published 18-11-2026

## TL;DR

The Court of Appeal upheld the Paris Central Division's revocation of VMR Products' vaporizer patent EP 3 456 214 for lack of inventive step, rejecting all ten auxiliary requests and every dependent claim. The decision also sets out what a revocation claimant may add in its Defence to an Application to amend the patent: new attacks on the patent as granted are excluded, but evidence on common general knowledge that responds to the defence may be admitted.

## Key holding

Under R 43.3 RoP, a claimant's Defence to an Application to amend the patent may contain submissions under R 44(d)-(h) RoP directed at the proposed amendments. It does not allow new grounds of invalidity against the patent as granted, such as new novelty-destroying prior art or new starting points for inventive step, unless leave to amend the case is granted under R 263 RoP. The front-loaded system requires each party to set out its full case early, but proportionality and fairness may justify admitting new facts and evidence in reply to the Statement of defence. This includes evidence proving a point on common general knowledge the claimant has already made, or rebutting the defendant's evidence on that point.

## Questions decided

1. May new prior art against the granted claims be introduced in the Defence to an Application to amend?
2. When may a revocation claimant file new evidence on common general knowledge in its reply?
3. Are new translations of prior art first filed on appeal admissible?
4. Does a general reference to first-instance submissions suffice on appeal?
5. Can an alleged synergy between features shape the objective problem without support in the patent?
6. Is a viewing window in a vaporizer shell obvious over Pan and common general knowledge?

## Case details

- Court: Court of Appeal of the Unified Patent Court, Panel 2
- Panel: Rian Kalden (presiding judge, legally qualified judge); Ingeborg Simonsson (legally qualified judge, judge-rapporteur); Patricia Rombach (legally qualified judge); Wiem Samoud (technically qualified judge); Andrea Scilletta (technically qualified judge)
- Date: 29-12-2025
- Case number(s): UPC CoA 71/2025, UPC CFI 308/2023
- Parties: Appellant: VMR Products LLC (defendant at first instance); Respondent: NJOY Netherlands B.V. (claimant at first instance)
- Language of the proceedings: English
- Outcome: The appeal is rejected. All other requests are rejected.

## How to cite

Court of Appeal, VMR Products LLC v NJOY Netherlands B.V., UPC CoA 71/2025, Decision of 29 December 2025 (OSCOLA)

## Full summary

Read the full analyses for free — create a free account: https://pitch.law/academy/upc-court-of-appeal/upc-coa-71-2025-2025-12-29

Topics: [Validity and revocation](https://pitch.law/academy/upc-court-of-appeal/topics/validity), [Procedure](https://pitch.law/academy/upc-court-of-appeal/topics/procedure)

## More on validity and revocation

- [Netflix Services Germany GmbH and others v DivX, LLC, UPC CoA 176/2026, 02-11-2026](https://pitch.law/academy/upc-court-of-appeal/upc-coa-176-2026-2026-11-02): The Court of Appeal refused Netflix's request for suspensive effect against the Munich Local Division's infringement decision in favour of DivX, even though the EPO Opposition Division revoked the patent after that decision.
- [Appellant (name not stated) v Amycel, LLC, UPC CoA 935/2025, 02-11-2026](https://pitch.law/academy/upc-court-of-appeal/upc-coa-935-2025-2026-11-02): The Court of Appeal set aside a decision by default of The Hague Local Division and allowed the defendant's application to have it set aside under R 356 RoP.
- [Barco N.V. v Yealink (Xiamen) Network Technology Co., Ltd. and others, UPC CoA 145/2026, 16-10-2026](https://pitch.law/academy/upc-court-of-appeal/upc-coa-145-2026-2026-10-16): The Court of Appeal upheld the Brussels Local Division's refusal to let Barco add a late auxiliary request (AR6) whose claim 1 is identical to dependent claim 9, a claim neither asserted for infringement nor attacked in the counterclaim for revocation.
- [Hurom Co., Ltd. v NUC Electronics Co., Ltd and others, UPC CoA 678/2025, 28-08-2026](https://pitch.law/academy/upc-court-of-appeal/upc-coa-678-2025-2026-08-28): The Court of Appeal upheld the Paris Local Division's revocation of Hurom's juicer patent EP 3 155 936 (as amended) for lack of inventive step, refused Hurom's new auxiliary requests filed only on appeal, and confirmed dismissal of all infringement claims, including those for Poland.
- [Xingi Technology CO., Ltd. and others v Avient Protective Materials B.V., UPC CoA 76/2026, 27-08-2026](https://pitch.law/academy/upc-court-of-appeal/upc-coa-76-2026-2026-08-27): The Court of Appeal upheld a Hague Local Division order requiring the Chinese defendants to deliver 30 kg each of two UD fabric variants to the claimant in the Netherlands, and to produce English-language versions of a company video, under R 190 RoP (court-ordered production of evidence held by the other side).
- [SharkNinja Operating LLC v Groupe SEB France and others, UPC CoA 61/2026, 21-08-2026](https://pitch.law/academy/upc-court-of-appeal/upc-coa-61-2026-2026-08-21): The Court of Appeal overturned the Paris Local Division and granted SharkNinja a provisional injunction in France and Germany against SEB's "Cookeo Infinity" multicookers.
