UPC Case Law
The Unified Patent Court has been hearing cases since 1 June 2023, and its Court of Appeal keeps adding to what is settled. Bart Lieben’s overview follows that case law chapter by chapter, from jurisdiction and procedure to claim interpretation, validity, infringement, urgent relief, remedies and appeals. The full text of the decisions behind it is available, searchable and linked paragraph by paragraph. It is written for readers who know the basics of the court and want to see how it reasons in practice. Access is on request.
On request9 chapters39 lessons4 h 18 minEdition: v1.0 – 10 November 2026
Course content
Free on request. This overview is open to everyone. The full content is free on request, with an account.
-
Introduction
1 lesson · 1 min
This short opening gives the argument of the study. It tells you what the overview aims to show and how to read it.
- The argument of this studyNew 1 min read
-
Part I: The legal framework and jurisdiction
5 lessons · 49 min
These chapters set out the framework the court works within: its sources of law and how it interprets them. They then turn to what it has jurisdiction over, how far its reach extends across borders and how cases are divided between its divisions.
- Chapter 1Introduction and methodologyNew 8 min read
- Chapter 2Sources of law and principles of interpretationNew 16 min read
- Chapter 3Subject matter jurisdiction and the transitional regimeNew 8 min read
- Chapter 4International jurisdiction and territorial reachNew 10 min read
- Chapter 5Allocation between divisions and coordination of actionsNew 7 min read
-
Part II: Parties procedure and access to justice
8 lessons · 50 min
This part explains who can bring and defend a case. It then follows the proceedings from start to finish: the language of the proceedings, service and time limits, pleadings, evidence, confidentiality and public access.
- Chapter 6Parties standing and representationNew 6 min read
- Chapter 7Judicial organisation and procedural safeguardsNew 7 min read
- Chapter 8Language of proceedingsNew 5 min read
- Chapter 9Commencement service and procedural time limitsNew 7 min read
- Chapter 10Pleadings and management of the caseNew 6 min read
- Chapter 11Evidence and proofNew 9 min read
- Chapter 12Confidentiality and sensitive informationNew 5 min read
- Chapter 13Public access and transparencyNew 5 min read
-
Part III: Substantive patent law
6 lessons · 1 h 5 min
This part covers the patent law the court applies. You see how claims are interpreted, when a patent is valid, how it can be amended and what counts as infringement, followed by the defences and how standard essential patents and FRAND terms are handled.
- Chapter 14Claim interpretationNew 12 min read
- Chapter 15Patent validityNew 17 min read
- Chapter 16Amendment of the patentNew 6 min read
- Chapter 17InfringementNew 11 min read
- Chapter 18Defences and limitations on rightsNew 6 min read
- Chapter 19Standard essential patents and FRANDNew 13 min read
-
Part IV: Urgent relief and preservation of evidence
2 lessons · 14 min
These two chapters cover the fast routes. They show how evidence can be preserved and inspected before a case is fully argued, and when the court orders provisional and protective measures.
- Chapter 20Preservation of evidence and inspectionNew 6 min read
- Chapter 21Provisional and protective measuresNew 8 min read
-
Part V: Final remedies enforcement and litigation costs
5 lessons · 35 min
This part covers what a winning party can obtain: injunctions and corrective measures, damages and enforcement. It also covers what proceedings cost, through court fees, costs and security, and how cases end by settlement or withdrawal.
- Chapter 22Injunctions and corrective measuresNew 8 min read
- Chapter 23Damages and compensationNew 7 min read
- Chapter 24Enforcement and complianceNew 6 min read
- Chapter 25Court fees costs and securityNew 9 min read
- Chapter 26Settlement withdrawal and terminationNew 5 min read
-
Part VI: Appeals review and interaction with other courts
3 lessons · 23 min
This part shows how decisions are challenged, through appeals and the appeal procedure and the standards the Court of Appeal applies when it reviews a decision. It also looks at how the court relates to the European Patent Office, national courts and the Court of Justice of the EU.
- Chapter 27Appeals and appellate procedureNew 6 min read
- Chapter 28Standards of review and corrective proceduresNew 8 min read
- Chapter 29Interaction with the EPO national courts and the CJEUNew 9 min read
-
Part VII: Synthesis and reference materials
1 lesson · 8 min
This chapter draws the case law together. It shows where the decisions converge, where they diverge and which questions are still open.
- Chapter 30Convergence divergence and questions still openNew 8 min read
-
Appendices
8 lessons · 13 min
The appendices are reference material for working with the overview: the authorities cited and indexes of cases, parties, legal issues, provisions and patents. They also show how decisions fared on appeal, the conventions used and how complete the coverage is.
- Appendix AAuthorities citedNew 5 min read
- Appendix BCase and party indexNew 1 min read
- Appendix DIndex by legal issueNew 1 min read
- Appendix EProvisions consideredNew 1 min read
- Appendix FTreatment on appealNew 1 min read
- Appendix GPatent and SPC indexNew 1 min read
- Appendix HTerminology and citation conventionsNew 1 min read
- Appendix ICoverage verification and update recordNew 2 min read
Total time: 4 h 18 min
UPC Court of Appeal decisions, summarised → Every Court of Appeal decision that lays down a rule, in a few minutes of reading. The full summaries are free with an Academy account.
We could not give you access this time. Questions? Write to [email protected], or ask again below.
Your request is in. We let you know by e-mail.
Access to this course is on request. Sign in or create a free account, then ask for access.
Read more in the Academy
-
The Unified Patent Court in brief
How the Unified Patent Court is organised, what it decides, how its proceedings differ from national courts, and what the opt-out means for your European patents.
-
The Unitary Patent
What unitary effect is, which states it covers in October 2026, how it differs from validating a European patent country by country, and when each route makes sense.