Skip to content
pitch

UPC Case Law

OrthoApnea S.L. and others v claimant (name not stated)

Order of the UPC Court of Appeal of 26 July 2024, UPC CFI 376/2023

UPC Case Law by Pitch, edited by Bart Lieben · Published

TL;DR

A request for suspensive effect (putting the first-instance order on hold pending the appeal) against a refusal to extend the deadline for a rejoinder can be admissible, because without it the appeal would become pointless. The standing judge of the Court of Appeal nevertheless rejected the request on the merits. Parties must plead without knowing how their arguments will be judged, and that risk alone does not justify freezing the written procedure.

Key holding

Under Art 74(1) UPCA and R 223 RoP, a request for suspensive effect against a first-instance order refusing to extend a time limit set by the Rules of Procedure for a written pleading may be admissible where, without it, the appeal against that refusal would become pointless. Suspensive effect still requires exceptional circumstances. The risk of incurring costs by answering an argument that may later be held inadmissible is not such a circumstance, since under the Rules of Procedure parties always file pleadings without knowing how the court will assess their positions. The fact that the appeal may become pointless is not decisive where the first-instance order is not manifestly wrong and an extension has already been granted.

Questions decided

  1. Is suspensive effect available against a refusal to extend the deadline for a rejoinder?
  2. Does the risk of answering an argument later held inadmissible justify suspensive effect?
  3. Is it decisive that refusing suspensive effect may make the appeal pointless?
  4. Can the standing judge decide requests concerning the substance of the appeal?
  5. Must the other party be heard before an urgent decision on suspensive effect?

Full summary

Read the full analyses for free — create a free account

With a free Academy account you read the full analysis of every Court of Appeal decision: the facts and procedure, the issues, the court’s reasoning and the practice points. Your name, an e-mail address and a password; no payment, and you can delete the account yourself at any time.

Create an account

At least 12 characters. A few words in a row make a strong password that’s easy to remember.

Already have an account?

In the same case

More on provisional measures

Provisional measures →

← All Court of Appeal summaries

Let’s talk

Tell us what you’re working on. We’ll get the right person on it and reply within one business day. The first chat is free.

Schedule a meeting