UPC Case Law
Centripetal Limited v Palo Alto Networks, Inc.
Order of the UPC Court of Appeal of 28 May 2025, UPC CoA 239/2025
UPC Case Law by Pitch, edited by Bart Lieben · Published
TL;DR
The Court of Appeal revoked the Mannheim Local Division's refusal to order preservation of evidence and inspection against Palo Alto Networks, Inc. and referred the case back for an ex parte order on narrower terms than Centripetal requested. The Court of Appeal held that Art 60 UPCA requires plausibility of infringement, a lower bar than proof on the merits. It also held that the measures ordered must be the least harmful of equally effective options: copies rather than seizure of originals, and a description rather than physical seizure of equipment.
Key holding
The requirement in Art 60(1) UPCA to present reasonably available evidence that a patent has been or is about to be infringed is a lower bar than the claimant's burden of proof in an infringement action. This is particularly so for aspects of the infringement for which no evidence is reasonably available to the applicant. Mere speculation is not enough: as a general rule, infringement must be plausible, especially where the order is sought without hearing the defendant. Because such measures interfere with Art 7 Charter rights, Art 60 UPCA may be used only to the extent necessary for effective enforcement, and where several equally effective measures exist, the one least harmful to the defendant must be chosen.
Questions decided
- What standard of proof applies to applications to preserve evidence under Art 60(1) UPCA?
- Must the applicant exclude technical alternatives to the patented solution?
- How does the necessity requirement limit the scope of preservation and inspection measures?
- When is physical seizure of equipment or original documents justified instead of description or copies?
- Does a risk of alteration of digital evidence justify an order without hearing the defendant?
- Should the Court of Appeal issue the preservation order itself or refer the case back?
Full summary
Read the full analyses for free — create a free account
With a free Academy account you read the full analysis of every Court of Appeal decision: the facts and procedure, the issues, the court’s reasoning and the practice points. Your name, an e-mail address and a password; no payment, and you can delete the account yourself at any time.
More on evidence, inspection and information
- Order · UPC CoA 113/2026
WEPA Nederland B.V. v Essity Hygiene and Health Aktiebolag
The Court of Appeal held that Art 60 UPCA does not allow the court to authorise a bailiff or expert to question the defendant's staff on technical details during an evidence-preservation measure.
- Order · UPC CoA 76/2026
Xingi Technology CO., Ltd. and others v Avient Protective Materials B.V.
The Court of Appeal upheld a Hague Local Division order requiring the Chinese defendants to deliver 30 kg each of two UD fabric variants to the claimant in the Netherlands, and to produce English-language versions of a company video, under R 190 RoP (court-ordered production of evidence held by the other side).
- Order · UPC CoA 69/2026
Network System Technologies LLC v Qualcomm Incorporated and others
A ruling on an evidence-production application under Art 59 UPCA / R 190 RoP must be appealed within 15 days of service, even where the Court of First Instance decides it inside its final decision on the merits.
- Order · UPC CoA 57/2026
Polytechnik Luft- und Feuerungstechnik GmbH v Dall Energy ApS
The Court of Appeal confirmed that a UPC court may order a defendant to produce internal technical documents to resolve disputed infringement facts, but cut the Copenhagen Local Division's order down to the single reference installation that was actually in dispute.
- Order · UPC CoA 48/2026
La Siddhi Consultancy Limited. v Athena Pharmaceutiques SAS and others
The Court of Appeal held that a claimant's status as a small or medium-sized enterprise (SME) does not, on its own, exempt it from providing security for costs under R 158 RoP.
- Order · UPC CoA 930/2025
EOFlow Co., Ltd. v Insulet Corporation
The Court of Appeal dismissed EOFlow's appeal against the refusal of its R. 262.2 RoP confidentiality requests.