UPC Case Law
Guangdong OPPO Mobile Telecommunications Corp. Ltd. and others v Panasonic Holdings Corporation
Order of the UPC Court of Appeal of 24 September 2024, UPC CoA 298/2024
UPC Case Law by Pitch, edited by Bart Lieben · Published
TL;DR
The Court of Appeal confirmed that a defendant may use R 190.1 RoP to ask the court to order the other side to produce evidence, including licence agreements needed for a FRAND defence (the argument that a standard-essential patent holder must offer a licence on fair, reasonable and non-discriminatory terms). It nonetheless dismissed OPPO's and OROPE's appeals. The Mannheim Local Division had discretion to refuse production at an early stage, before it had ruled on the defendants' willingness to take a licence, and may revisit the requests later.
Key holding
A defendant can rely on R 190.1 RoP and Art 59 UPCA to request an order to produce (counter-)evidence. The defendant's interest in evidence supporting a FRAND defence must be balanced against the interest of the patent holder and its contracting parties in protecting confidential information. The Court of First Instance has a margin of discretion when deciding such a request, which includes deciding it in line with the order in which issues are to be decided under R 334(e) RoP. A request may fail the criteria of necessity, relevance and proportionality at one stage of the proceedings and meet them at a later stage.
Questions decided
- Is an appeal admissible against an order rejecting a request to produce evidence under R 220.1(c) RoP?
- Can a defendant rely on R 190.1 RoP to obtain counter-evidence?
- How are FRAND disclosure interests weighed against confidentiality of licence agreements?
- May the first instance refuse production because of the stage the proceedings have reached?
- Must a party seek its contracting partners' consent before asking for an order against itself?
- Is a costs order made on an appeal that does not end the action?
Full summary
Read the full analyses for free — create a free account
With a free Academy account you read the full analysis of every Court of Appeal decision: the facts and procedure, the issues, the court’s reasoning and the practice points. Your name, an e-mail address and a password; no payment, and you can delete the account yourself at any time.
In the same case
- Order · UPC CoA 476/2023
Guangdong OPPO Mobile Telecommunications Corp. Ltd. and others v Panasonic Holdings Corporation
The Court of Appeal refused OPPO's request to shorten Panasonic's time to respond to an appeal on the language of proceedings, even though OPPO consequently had to file its statement of defence at first instance in German.
- Order · UPC CoA 472/2023
Guangdong OPPO Mobile Telecommunications Corp. Ltd. and others v Panasonic Holdings Corporation
The Court of Appeal refused to shorten the respondent's 15-day period to answer an appeal on the language of proceedings.
More on evidence, inspection and information
- Order · UPC CoA 113/2026
WEPA Nederland B.V. v Essity Hygiene and Health Aktiebolag
The Court of Appeal held that Art 60 UPCA does not allow the court to authorise a bailiff or expert to question the defendant's staff on technical details during an evidence-preservation measure.
- Order · UPC CoA 76/2026
Xingi Technology CO., Ltd. and others v Avient Protective Materials B.V.
The Court of Appeal upheld a Hague Local Division order requiring the Chinese defendants to deliver 30 kg each of two UD fabric variants to the claimant in the Netherlands, and to produce English-language versions of a company video, under R 190 RoP (court-ordered production of evidence held by the other side).
- Order · UPC CoA 69/2026
Network System Technologies LLC v Qualcomm Incorporated and others
A ruling on an evidence-production application under Art 59 UPCA / R 190 RoP must be appealed within 15 days of service, even where the Court of First Instance decides it inside its final decision on the merits.
- Order · UPC CoA 57/2026
Polytechnik Luft- und Feuerungstechnik GmbH v Dall Energy ApS
The Court of Appeal confirmed that a UPC court may order a defendant to produce internal technical documents to resolve disputed infringement facts, but cut the Copenhagen Local Division's order down to the single reference installation that was actually in dispute.