Skip to content
pitch

UPC Case Law

Apple Retail Germany B.V. & Co. KG and others v Ona Patents SL

Order of the UPC Court of Appeal of 18 September 2024, UPC CoA 354/2024

UPC Case Law by Pitch, edited by Bart Lieben · Published

TL;DR

The Court of Appeal set aside the refusal to switch an infringement action against Apple from German to English and ordered that the proceedings continue in English, the language of the patent. Under Art 49(5) UPCA, a defendant group whose internal working language and technical experts are English-speaking can show real unfairness. A claimant whose decision-maker is fluent in English cannot defeat the switch by pointing to German parallel litigation or to its smaller size.

Key holding

When deciding under Art 49(5) UPCA whether, on grounds of fairness, the language in which the patent was granted should become the language of proceedings, the internal working language of the parties and the possibility of internal coordination and technical support are relevant circumstances. Other proceedings between the parties pending before a national court relate neither to the dispute nor to the parties and are of less relevance. Where the claimant needs no translations in either language and the defendant would need them, fairness requires a change to the language of the patent.

Questions decided

  1. Are a party's internal working language and access to technical experts relevant under Art 49(5) UPCA?
  2. How much weight do parallel national proceedings in German carry?
  3. Does a claimant's preference for German count where its decision-maker is fluent in English?
  4. Does a German-speaking in-house coordinator remove the defendant's disadvantage?
  5. Is a language change unreasonable once the claimant is preparing its reply?
  6. Are the language skills of the Local Division judges relevant?

Full summary

Read the full analyses for free — create a free account

With a free Academy account you read the full analysis of every Court of Appeal decision: the facts and procedure, the issues, the court’s reasoning and the practice points. Your name, an e-mail address and a password; no payment, and you can delete the account yourself at any time.

Create an account

At least 12 characters. A few words in a row make a strong password that’s easy to remember.

Already have an account?

In the same case

More on procedure

Procedure →

← All Court of Appeal summaries

Let’s talk

Tell us what you’re working on. We’ll get the right person on it and reply within one business day. The first chat is free.

Schedule a meeting