UPC Case Law
Netgear Inc. and others v Huawei Technologies Co. Ltd
Order of the UPC Court of Appeal of 21 March 2024, UPC CoA 486/2023
UPC Case Law by Pitch, edited by Bart Lieben · Published
TL;DR
The Court of Appeal set aside a Munich Local Division judge-rapporteur's order that had rejected, as inadmissible, a request for panel review of his decision to defer the defendants' preliminary objection to the main proceedings. Only the panel may decide on an application under R 333.1 RoP, including its admissibility. A judge-rapporteur's choice to deal with a preliminary objection in the main proceedings is a case management decision that the panel can review.
Key holding
Unless otherwise provided, a case management decision or order of the judge-rapporteur or presiding judge cannot be appealed directly. The remedy is an application for panel review under R 333.1 RoP, whose admissibility the panel alone decides (R 333.4 RoP). The panel's resulting order may be appealed under R 220.2 RoP or made the subject of a request for discretionary review under R 220.3 RoP. A judge-rapporteur's decision under R 20.2 RoP to deal with a preliminary objection in the main proceedings is a reviewable case management decision.
Questions decided
- May the judge-rapporteur decide alone on the admissibility of an application for panel review under R 333.1 RoP?
- Is an R 20.2 RoP notification deferring a preliminary objection a reviewable case management decision?
- Can a judge-rapporteur's case management order be appealed without prior panel review?
- Is discretionary review under R 220.3 RoP available where the judge-rapporteur wrongly decided instead of the panel?
- What remedies exist against a judge-rapporteur's order rejecting a preliminary objection?
- Should the Court of Appeal remit or decide itself when the panel never ruled on the merits?
Full summary
Read the full analyses for free — create a free account
With a free Academy account you read the full analysis of every Court of Appeal decision: the facts and procedure, the issues, the court’s reasoning and the practice points. Your name, an e-mail address and a password; no payment, and you can delete the account yourself at any time.
In the same case
- Order · UPC CoA 36/2024
Netgear Inc. and others v Huawei Technologies Co. Ltd
The Court of Appeal held that when a claimant adds a further patent to pending infringement proceedings under R 263 RoP, the defendant must get the same period to file a statement of defence (and any counterclaim for revocation) on the new patent as if a separate action had been brought.
- Order · UPC CoA 44/2024
Netgear Inc. and others v Huawei Technologies Co. Ltd
When a claimant adds a further patent to a pending infringement action under R 263 RoP, the defendant must get the same time to file a defence, and where relevant a counterclaim for revocation, as it would have had against a separate new action.
- Order · UPC CoA 44/2024
Netgear Inc. and others v Huawei Technologies Co. Ltd
The Court of Appeal refused to shorten the respondent's 15-day period for its Statement of response in an appeal against an order separating part of an action.
More on jurisdiction and competence
- Decision · UPC CoA 678/2025
Hurom Co., Ltd. v NUC Electronics Co., Ltd and others
The Court of Appeal upheld the Paris Local Division's revocation of Hurom's juicer patent EP 3 155 936 (as amended) for lack of inventive step, refused Hurom's new auxiliary requests filed only on appeal, and confirmed dismissal of all infringement claims, including those for Poland.
- Decision · UPC CoA 365/2025
Knaus Tabbert AG v Yellow Sphere Innovations GmbH and others
The Court of Appeal dismissed Knaus Tabbert's appeals and upheld the Düsseldorf Local Division's finding that its caravan frames infringe EP 3 356 109, which remains valid.
- Decision · UPC CoA 473/2025
Fujifilm Corporation v Kodak GmbH and others
The Court of Appeal reversed the Mannheim Local Division and held Fujifilm's lithographic printing plate patent (EP 3 476 616, as centrally limited) valid and infringed by Kodak's Sonora plates in Germany, granting an injunction, damages, information, recall and destruction.