Skip to content
pitch

Preliminary injunctions at the UPC: provisional measures explained

A preliminary injunction can stop an infringing product within weeks, across every UPC country. Here is what the court needs to see before it grants one, and what you can do if one is aimed at you.

By
By
Published

What provisional measures are

A full infringement action takes about a year at first instance. When a competitor launches a product that copies your invention, a year can be too long. Provisional measures fill that gap. The court can order an injunction against the alleged infringer, the seizure or delivery up of products suspected of infringing, and other measures meant to protect your position until the case is decided on the merits (Art 62(1) and (3) UPCA).

The procedure is set out in R 205 to R 213 RoP. Because the UPC covers all its member states at once, a single order can reach a market of several hundred million people. That is why the court asks a lot of the applicant.

What the applicant has to show

Entitlement and infringement, more likely than not

The court may require the applicant to provide reasonably available evidence to satisfy it with a sufficient degree of certainty that the applicant is entitled to start proceedings, that the patent is valid and that it is infringed or about to be infringed (Art 62(4) UPCA; R 211.2 RoP).

The Court of Appeal has said what "sufficient degree of certainty" means. The court must consider it at least more likely than not that the applicant is entitled to sue and that the patent is infringed. It falls short where the court thinks it more likely than not that the patent is invalid. The applicant carries the burden on entitlement and infringement; outside ex parte proceedings, the defendant carries it on invalidity (NanoString v 10x Genomics (UPC CoA 335/2023)). The court applied the same balance-of-probabilities test a year later (SharkNinja v Dyson (UPC CoA 297/2024)).

In practice, the validity attack is where many applications are won or lost. Expect the defendant to bring its best prior art, and prepare your answer before you file.

Urgency

Provisional measures are for situations that cannot wait. The court takes into account any unreasonable delay in seeking them (R 211.4 RoP), and the application itself has to explain why the measures are needed (R 206 RoP).

Delay is measured patent by patent. A patent holder does not have to bring all its patents in one application, and waiting until it can assert all of them may itself be an unreasonable delay. If you rely on technical analysis to explain the time you took, be specific: which analysis, for which patent and which features, and how long it took (Guardant v Sophia Genetics (UPC CoA 19/2026)). The possibility that the defendant might change its product does not, as a rule, justify waiting either (Barco v Yealink (UPC CoA 317/2025)).

A practical rule of thumb: start preparing the day you learn of the infringement, and keep a record of every step.

The balance of interests

Even with a strong case, the court weighs the interests of both parties, and in particular the potential harm to either side of granting or refusing the injunction (Art 62(2) UPCA; R 211.3 RoP). A product that is central to the defendant's business, or a market where damages would make the patent holder whole, can tip the balance.

Security and compensation

The court can make the measures conditional on the applicant providing adequate security, to cover any harm the defendant may suffer if the measures are later revoked (Art 62(5) UPCA, which applies Art 60(7) UPCA by analogy; R 211.5 RoP).

That harm is real. If the measures are revoked, lapse because of an act or omission of the applicant, or it later turns out there was no infringement, the court may order the applicant to compensate the defendant (Art 62(5) with Art 60(9) UPCA; R 213.2 RoP).

Ex parte orders and protective letters

In urgent cases, the court can order measures without hearing the defendant first, in particular where any delay is likely to cause irreparable harm to the patent holder (R 212 RoP). Such an order is the exception. The applicant must be candid with the court, since the defendant cannot correct the picture.

If you expect an application against you, you can file a protective letter with the court in advance, setting out why an injunction should not be granted (R 207 RoP). The court takes it into account when it receives an application against you. A protective letter stays on file for six months and can be extended (R 207.9 RoP). It is an inexpensive way to make sure the judge hears your side before deciding whether to grant an order without a hearing.

After the order: starting the main action

Provisional measures are, as the name says, provisional. If the applicant does not start proceedings on the merits within 31 calendar days or 20 working days, whichever is longer, the court will on the defendant's request revoke the measures (Art 62(5) with Art 60(8) UPCA; R 213.1 and R 198 RoP). The period runs from the date specified in the order.

When an injunction is set aside

An order on provisional measures can be appealed within 15 days of service (Art 73(2)(a) UPCA; R 220.1(c) and R 224.1(b) RoP). On appeal, the Court of Appeal in principle looks only at what was put forward in the provisional measures proceedings themselves, not at pleadings from the main action (Mammut v Ortovox (UPC CoA 182/2024)).

If the Court of Appeal sets a preliminary injunction aside, that as a rule has retroactive effect: the order is treated as never having had legal effect. That also removes the basis for penalty payments, even for breaches committed while the injunction was still in force (NanoString v 10x Genomics (UPC CoA 470/2023)). For a defendant, an appeal can therefore be worth pursuing even after it has complied.

Where to go next

The main action that has to follow an injunction is described in an infringement action step by step. Appeals against orders, including the short 15-day deadline, are covered in appeals to the Court of Appeal.

Read the full analyses for free — create a free account

With a free Academy account you read the full analysis of every Court of Appeal decision: the facts and procedure, the issues, the court’s reasoning and the practice points. Your name, an e-mail address and a password; no payment, and you can delete the account yourself at any time.

Create a free accountAlready have an account? Sign in

Let’s talk

Tell us what you’re working on. We’ll get the right person on it and reply within one business day. The first chat is free.

Schedule a meeting