Skip to content
pitch

A UPC infringement action, step by step

The UPC aims to decide an infringement case at first instance in about a year. That pace depends on a tight timetable and on parties putting their full case on the table early. Here is how the stages fit together.

By
By
Published

The shape of a case

An infringement action at the UPC has three stages: a written procedure, an interim procedure and an oral procedure (Art 52 UPCA). The Rules of Procedure set the goal that the final oral hearing on infringement and validity should normally take place within one year (Preamble to the RoP, recital 7). Most cases come close.

That speed comes at a price. The UPC is front-loaded: you are expected to set out your full case, with your evidence, at the start. Arguments held back for later may not be heard. If you are thinking of suing, much of the work happens before you file.

The written procedure

The statement of claim

The claimant starts the case with a statement of claim (R 13 RoP). It names the parties and the patent, identifies the division chosen and explains why it is competent, and sets out the facts, the evidence, the arguments and the remedies sought. It should also give an indication of the value of the dispute. The Registry checks the formal requirements and the court fee before the claim is served (R 16 RoP).

Service on a defendant abroad can take time. For defendants in a Hague Convention country, the court expects a Hague Convention method to be tried first before it allows service by other means (NEC v TCL (UPC CoA 69/2024)). Plan for that when the defendant is outside the EU.

The defendant's response

A defendant that wants to challenge the court's jurisdiction or competence, or the language of the claim, must lodge a preliminary objection within one month of service of the statement of claim (R 19 RoP). The grounds listed in R 19.1 RoP are exhaustive (Roku v Dolby (UPC CoA 288/2025)).

The statement of defence is due within three months of service of the statement of claim (R 23 RoP). It answers the infringement claim and very often includes a counterclaim for revocation of the patent (R 25 RoP). That counterclaim brings validity into the same case, and the patent holder may respond with an application to amend the patent (R 30 RoP). How the court handles a counterclaim, and when it is sent to the central division, is the subject of revocation actions and counterclaims.

Reply and rejoinder

Then come further rounds: the claimant's reply to the defence (and, where there is a counterclaim, its defence to it), followed by the defendant's rejoinder, each with its own time limit (R 29 RoP). The time limits are tight, typically one or two months per round.

Further written pleadings beyond these are the exception. The judge-rapporteur can allow them only on a reasoned request made before the written procedure closes, and after the oral hearing there is no room for them at all (expert klein v Seoul Viosys (UPC CoA 764/2024); R 36 RoP).

Keeping to your case

Changing your claim or amending your case later needs the court's leave (R 263 RoP). Not every new argument is such an amendment: that happens where the nature or scope of the dispute changes, for example when you rely on another patent or target another product. A new argument that stays within the case can still be refused if it should have come earlier (OrthoApnea (UPC CoA 456/2024)).

The interim procedure

Once the written procedure closes, the judge-rapporteur prepares the case for the oral hearing (R 101 RoP). That usually includes an interim conference with the parties, to identify the main issues, clarify positions, discuss settlement and fix the schedule (R 104 RoP). The judge-rapporteur can also order further steps, such as experts or experiments, and decides on the value of the dispute in this phase (Microsoft v Suinno (UPC CoA 826/2024)).

A stay of proceedings is rare. A parallel opposition at the European Patent Office is not enough on its own: a stay is possible only when a rapid EPO decision may be expected, and even then the court weighs the parties' interests (Carrier v BITZER (UPC CoA 22/2024); Art 33(10) UPCA; R 295(a) RoP).

The oral procedure

The oral hearing is held before the full panel, and the presiding judge leads it (R 111 to R 119 RoP). It is usually a single day. The judges have read the file, so the hearing focuses on the points they consider decisive. Witnesses and experts can be heard where the court has ordered it.

The decision

The court aims to give its decision in writing soon after the hearing (R 118 RoP). If it finds infringement, it can grant an injunction against the infringer (Art 63 UPCA), order corrective measures such as recall and destruction of products (Art 64 UPCA), order the infringer to provide information on the origin and distribution of the products (Art 67 UPCA) and order publication of the decision (Art 80 UPCA). The decision also deals with costs in principle; the amount follows in a separate cost procedure, covered in costs, security for costs and the value of the dispute.

Damages: often a second step

The court can award damages for the harm caused by the infringement (Art 68 UPCA). In practice the decision on the merits often establishes the duty to pay damages, and the amount is decided later in a separate procedure for the determination of damages (R 125 to R 144 RoP). An application for that procedure must be made within one year of service of the final decision on the merits (R 126 RoP).

In that procedure, the claimant can ask the court to order the infringer to lay open its books, so the damages can be calculated (R 141 RoP). Such a request belongs to the damages procedure, with its own court fees (Bruker v 10x Genomics (UPC CoA 681/2025)).

Where to go next

If the defendant counterclaims for revocation, read revocation actions and counterclaims. For what follows a decision you disagree with, see appeals to the Court of Appeal.

Read the full analyses for free — create a free account

With a free Academy account you read the full analysis of every Court of Appeal decision: the facts and procedure, the issues, the court’s reasoning and the practice points. Your name, an e-mail address and a password; no payment, and you can delete the account yourself at any time.

Create a free accountAlready have an account? Sign in

Let’s talk

Tell us what you’re working on. We’ll get the right person on it and reply within one business day. The first chat is free.

Schedule a meeting