Costs, security for costs and the value of the dispute at the UPC
At the UPC the losing party pays a large share of the winner's legal costs, up to a ceiling that depends on what the case is worth. Here is how costs, court fees and security for costs work, and which deadlines to watch.
- By
- By Bart Lieben
- Published
The basic rule: the loser pays
The UPC follows a loser-pays system. The reasonable and proportionate legal costs and other expenses of the successful party are borne by the unsuccessful party, unless equity requires otherwise (Art 69(1) UPCA). Where each party wins on some points, or in exceptional circumstances, the court can split the costs or let each side bear its own (Art 69(2) UPCA). A party that causes the court or the other side unnecessary costs should pay for them (Art 69(3) UPCA).
That makes a UPC case a real financial decision for both sides. Before you start, or before you decide how hard to fight, it is worth estimating what you could recover and what you could be ordered to pay.
How the amount is fixed
The decision on the merits usually says who bears the costs. The amount follows in separate cost proceedings (R 150 RoP). The successful party has to apply for a cost decision within one month of service of the decision (R 151 RoP), setting out the costs it claims and supporting them.
That month is strict. The Court of Appeal treats it as a hard cut-off: once it has passed, the right to ask for costs is gone, and the court's general power to extend time limits does not help. Only re-establishment of rights can rescue a missed deadline (Hanshow v VusionGroup (UPC CoA 618/2024)). The period runs from service of the decision on the merits, not from an earlier order on provisional measures, and a request to extend or suspend it made before that decision is premature (SharkNinja v Dyson (UPC CoA 297/2024)).
Ceilings and the value of the dispute
Recoverable representation costs are capped. The Administrative Committee of the court has adopted a scale of ceilings (R 152 RoP), set per instance and rising with the value of the dispute. The more the case is worth, the higher the cap. The scale also allows the court to raise the ceiling in particularly complex cases and to lower it where the full amount would threaten the economic existence of a party, such as a small company.
The value of the dispute therefore matters well beyond the fees. The claimant states it in the statement of claim (R 13 RoP), and the court settles it during the proceedings, usually by the interim conference (R 104 RoP). Guidelines of the Administrative Committee explain how it is assessed, often by reference to a licence fee for the use complained of.
Court fees
Court fees are paid in advance, unless the Rules of Procedure say otherwise (Art 70 UPCA). For actions such as an infringement action there is a fixed fee and, above a threshold value of the dispute, an additional value-based fee (R 370 RoP). A stand-alone revocation action carries a fixed fee only. A fee counts as paid on time if a bank has been instructed to transfer the amount when the pleading is lodged, provided the money then arrives (Sumi Agro v Syngenta (UPC CoA 286/2025)).
Small and micro enterprises pay a reduced share of the fixed and value-based fees (R 370.8 RoP). The declaration has to be accurate: when it turns out to be wrong, the court can order payment of the rest of the fee plus a surcharge (Appellant v Amycel (UPC CoA 490/2024)).
Part of the fees comes back in some situations, for example when an action is withdrawn at an early stage (R 370.9 RoP). The refund percentages were changed on 1 January 2026. For actions filed after 31 December 2025, a withdrawal before the written procedure closes now returns 50% of the fees (Juul Labs v NJOY (UPC CoA 328/2025)). A party that cannot afford the proceedings can apply for legal aid (Art 71 UPCA, R 375 RoP onwards).
Security for costs
A defendant who fears it will never recover its costs from the claimant can ask the court to order the claimant to provide adequate security, as a deposit or a bank guarantee (Art 69(4) UPCA, R 158 RoP). It is a common request against claimants based outside the EU or companies set up only to enforce patents.
The defendant has to give credible reasons and facts; it does not have to prove the claimant is or will be insolvent. The claimant, who knows its own finances, must then rebut them in a substantiated way (Audi v Network System Technologies (UPC CoA 217/2024)). What counts is the claimant's own financial position. Being part of a wealthy group does not help without a guarantee from that group, and the defendant only needs to show that enforcing a costs order would be unduly burdensome (Aarke v SodaStream (UPC CoA 548/2024)).
Security works in one direction. Art 69(4) UPCA gives the right to ask for it to the defendant, so a claimant cannot ask for security from a defendant who has filed a counterclaim for revocation (AorticLab v Emboline (UPC CoA 393/2025)). The request can be made at any time during the proceedings, also on appeal, but it has to come before the court decides on costs (Bhagat v Oerlikon (UPC CoA 8/2025)).
If the claimant does not provide the security within the time set, the court can give a decision by default (R 158 RoP, R 355 RoP). For a claimant that can mean losing the case without a ruling on the patent.
What this means for you
Put the cost risk on the table early. If you are the claimant, budget for your own costs, the court fees and a possible adverse costs order up to the ceiling, and be ready to show your finances if security is requested. If you are the defendant, check early whether a request for security makes sense. And whoever wins, diarise the one-month deadline for the cost application the day the decision is served.
Where to go next
For the steps of the case these costs attach to, read An infringement action step by step. Costs on appeal are covered in Appeals to the Court of Appeal.