Skip to content
pitch

Appeals to the UPC Court of Appeal

Every first-instance decision of the UPC can go to one Court of Appeal in Luxembourg, but orders follow stricter rules and much shorter deadlines. Here is what can be appealed, when, and what to expect once the appeal is lodged.

By
By
Published

One Court of Appeal for the whole system

Appeals from every local, regional and central division go to the same Court of Appeal, which sits in Luxembourg. Its panels have five judges: three legally qualified judges of different nationalities and two technically qualified judges (Art 9(1) UPCA). That single court is a large part of what makes UPC case law consistent across countries, and its decisions are quickly becoming the reference point for practitioners.

An appeal can be based on points of law and on matters of fact (Art 73(3) UPCA). The Court of Appeal looks at the case again, though within limits on new material set out below.

What you can appeal

Any party that has lost in whole or in part can appeal (Art 73(1) UPCA). The rules distinguish three groups (R 220.1 RoP):

  • final decisions of the Court of First Instance;
  • decisions that end the proceedings as regards one of the parties;
  • orders on the language of proceedings under Art 49(5) UPCA, and orders under Art 59 to 62 and Art 67 UPCA: production and preservation of evidence, freezing orders, provisional measures and orders to communicate information.

Every other order can be appealed only together with the appeal against the final decision, or with leave of the Court of First Instance (Art 73(2)(b) UPCA, R 220.2 RoP). An appeal against such an order filed without leave is inadmissible from the outset (Abbott v DexCom (UPC CoA 5/2024)).

If leave is refused, you can ask the Court of Appeal for discretionary review (R 220.3 RoP). That is no second appeal: the request succeeds only if the first instance misread the rules or went beyond its discretion, or if there is some other urgent need (Xiaomi v Panasonic (UPC CoA 543/2024)).

Case management orders go to the panel first

Many orders in a UPC case are made by the judge-rapporteur or the presiding judge alone, such as orders setting time limits or deciding how to handle a procedural objection. They cannot be appealed directly. The first step is an application for review by the panel (R 333 RoP); only the panel's order can then go further under R 220.2 or R 220.3 RoP (Netgear v Huawei (UPC CoA 486/2023)). This also applies to an order for security for costs made by the judge-rapporteur, even if the order itself says it can be appealed (Chint v JingAo (UPC CoA 430/2025)).

The time limits

The deadlines are short and the court applies them strictly.

For a decision, the statement of appeal is due within two months of service of the decision (Art 73(1) UPCA, R 224.1(a) RoP), and the statement of grounds of appeal within four months of service (R 224.2(a) RoP).

For an appealable order, everything happens within 15 days of service: the statement of appeal and the statement of grounds (Art 73(2) UPCA, R 224.1(b) and R 224.2(b) RoP). A first-instance court cannot give you a different period (AIM Sport v Supponor (UPC CoA 500/2023)).

The respondent then files a statement of response, as a rule within three months of service of the statement of grounds, and within much less for orders (R 235 RoP). A respondent who wants to change the outcome in its own favour can lodge a cross-appeal with its response (R 237 RoP).

What goes into the grounds

The statement of grounds must explain why the decision or order should be set aside (R 226 RoP). A general line saying that everything argued at first instance is maintained is not enough, because those arguments were written before the decision existed (SharkNinja v Dyson (UPC CoA 297/2024)).

New facts and evidence

The appeal is no fresh start. New facts and evidence may be introduced only in line with the rules and where they could not reasonably have been submitted at first instance (Art 73(4) UPCA). The Court of Appeal may disregard requests, facts and evidence that were not submitted at first instance (R 222.2 RoP).

New legal arguments are a different matter. As long as they rest on facts and evidence already before the first instance, they are allowed, including on claim interpretation (Meril v Edwards (UPC CoA 511/2024), Hartmann Packaging v Omni-Pac (UPC CoA 908/2025)). The practical lesson: put all your facts and evidence on the table at first instance.

Does the appeal put the decision on hold?

As a rule, no. An appeal has no suspensive effect unless the Court of Appeal decides otherwise on a reasoned request (Art 74(1) UPCA, R 223 RoP). So an injunction granted at first instance can be enforced while the appeal is pending. The court grants suspensive effect only in exceptional circumstances, which the applicant has to show (Bhagat v Oerlikon (UPC CoA 12/2025)), for example where the decision under appeal is manifestly wrong on the reasoning it actually gives (Belkin v Philips (UPC CoA 549/2024)).

There is one exception. An appeal against a decision on a revocation action or a counterclaim for revocation always has suspensive effect (Art 74(2) UPCA). An appeal against one of the orders listed above does not stop the main proceedings from carrying on (Art 74(3) UPCA).

The outcome

If the appeal succeeds, the Court of Appeal sets the decision aside and gives a final decision itself (Art 75(1) UPCA). Only in exceptional cases does it refer the case back to the first instance (Art 75(2) UPCA, R 242 RoP). Even where the first instance revoked the patent and never looked at infringement, the Court of Appeal will normally decide infringement itself (Rematec v Europe Forestry (UPC CoA 302/2025)).

What this means for you

Diarise the deadline the day a decision or order is served, and check first whether the order can be appealed at all or needs leave or panel review. Build your first-instance case as if there will be no chance to add evidence later. And if you lose at first instance, assume the decision can be enforced against you while the appeal runs.

Where to go next

The most common orders on appeal are provisional measures: see Provisional measures and preliminary injunctions. What an appeal costs is in Costs, security for costs and the value of the dispute.

Read the full analyses for free — create a free account

With a free Academy account you read the full analysis of every Court of Appeal decision: the facts and procedure, the issues, the court’s reasoning and the practice points. Your name, an e-mail address and a password; no payment, and you can delete the account yourself at any time.

Create a free accountAlready have an account? Sign in

Let’s talk

Tell us what you’re working on. We’ll get the right person on it and reply within one business day. The first chat is free.

Schedule a meeting