Revocation actions and counterclaims at the UPC
A patent can be knocked out at the UPC in one action for all the countries it covers. Here is how a revocation action works, how it meets an infringement case, and how the patentee can defend the patent by amending it.
- By
- By Bart Lieben
- Published
Two ways to attack a patent
At the Unified Patent Court a patent can be challenged in two ways. You can start a stand-alone revocation action (Art 32(1)(d) UPCA), usually because you want to clear the way for a product before anyone sues you. Or, once you have been sued for infringement, you can hit back with a counterclaim for revocation (Art 32(1)(e) UPCA). Both are within the court's exclusive competence for patents that fall under its jurisdiction (Art 32(1) UPCA).
The stakes are high on both sides. A single decision can revoke a European patent for every Contracting Member State in which it has effect, and a unitary patent as a whole. A patent that is revoked is treated as never having had the effects of a patent, to the extent it was revoked (Art 65(4) UPCA).
Where the case is heard
A stand-alone revocation action goes to the central division (Art 33(4) UPCA). There is one exception. If an infringement action between the same parties on the same patent is already pending before a local or regional division, the revocation action can only be brought before that same division (Art 33(4) UPCA).
It also works the other way round. When a revocation action is pending before the central division, the patentee can still sue the same party for infringement before a local or regional division, or before the central division itself (Art 33(5) UPCA).
The grounds you can rely on
The court can revoke a patent only on the grounds in Art 138(1) and Art 139(2) EPC (Art 65(2) UPCA). In practice that means lack of novelty or inventive step, insufficient disclosure, added matter, extension of the scope of protection after grant, and a proprietor who was not entitled to the patent (Art 138(1) EPC). Where the grounds affect only part of the patent, it is limited by amending the claims and revoked in part (Art 65(3) UPCA).
Added matter comes up often. The Court of Appeal compares the patent with what the skilled person would derive directly and unambiguously from the application as filed, read as a whole and with common general knowledge. For a patent from a divisional, that test applies to each earlier application, including the original PCT application (expert e-Commerce v Seoul Viosys (UPC CoA 764/2024)). Claiming some features of an embodiment while leaving out others that are inextricably linked to them is, as a rule, not allowed either (Sibio v Abbott (UPC CoA 884/2025)).
The counterclaim inside an infringement case
A defendant who wants to challenge validity puts the counterclaim for revocation in its statement of defence (R 25 RoP), which is due within three months of service of the statement of claim (R 23 RoP). The patentee then answers the counterclaim in its reply, and the written exchanges continue under R 29 RoP.
A counterclaim does not have to be unconditional. The Court of Appeal has accepted a counterclaim limited to the case where infringement is found, and it explained what that means for an appeal against a finding of non-infringement (Emboline v AorticLab (UPC CoA 40/2026)).
Bifurcation: who decides validity
Once a counterclaim is filed before a local or regional division, that division has a choice (Art 33(3) UPCA). It can hear both the infringement action and the counterclaim itself, with a technically qualified judge added to the panel. It can refer the counterclaim to the central division and either suspend the infringement case or carry on with it. Or, if the parties agree, it can refer the whole case to the central division.
The division decides how to proceed after hearing the parties, as a rule once the written procedure has closed (R 37 RoP). So far most local divisions have kept both parts of the case together, which gives one decision on infringement and validity at the same time. That is a practice, though, and each division weighs it case by case.
Defending the patent by amending it
The patentee does not have to defend the patent only as granted. It can apply to amend the patent (R 30 RoP), proposing one or more amended sets of claims as auxiliary requests. The application is filed with the defence to the counterclaim, or with the defence in a stand-alone revocation action (R 49 RoP). Later amendments need the court's permission (R 30.2 RoP).
Amended claims must survive the same grounds as the granted ones, and they cannot extend the protection the patent gave (Art 138(1)(d) EPC). Defending dependent claims that are already in the patent does not need an application to amend, but the patentee must say clearly which dependent claims, and which combinations, it says are valid if the independent claim falls (Fujifilm v Kodak (UPC CoA 473/2025)).
Running next to an EPO opposition
A European patent can also be opposed at the European Patent Office within nine months of grant (Art 99(1) EPC), and the two procedures can run at the same time. The UPC may stay its own proceedings when a rapid decision of the EPO may be expected (Art 33(10) UPCA, R 295(a) RoP).
Do not count on a stay. The Court of Appeal has said that, as a general principle, the UPC does not stay proceedings, and that a parallel opposition alone is no reason to do so. Even when a quick EPO decision is in sight, a stay is discretionary and depends on the balance of the parties' interests (Carrier v BITZER (UPC CoA 22/2024)).
On appeal
A decision on a revocation action or counterclaim can be appealed to the Court of Appeal, and such an appeal always has suspensive effect (Art 74(2) UPCA). If the Court of Appeal reverses a revocation, it will normally go on to decide the infringement case too, rather than send it back to the first instance (Rematec v Europe Forestry (UPC CoA 302/2025)).
What this means for you
If you are planning a launch and see a patent in your way, a revocation action at the central division can clear it for many countries at once. If you are sued, the counterclaim is your main defence, and it has to be ready within three months. And if you own the patent, prepare your fallback claims early: a well-chosen set of auxiliary requests often decides whether a patent survives.
Where to go next
How the infringement side of the case runs is in An infringement action step by step. What a lost revocation case costs is in Costs, security for costs and the value of the dispute.