Skip to content
pitch

UPC Case Law

Volkswagen AG v Network System Technologies LLC

Order of the UPC Court of Appeal of 17 September 2024, UPC CoA 218/2024

UPC Case Law by Pitch, edited by Bart Lieben · Published

TL;DR

The Court of Appeal set aside three Munich Local Division orders and required Network System Technologies LLC, a US patent enforcement company with two employees, to provide security for Volkswagen's costs totalling EUR 500,000. Once a defendant credibly shows a real risk that a costs order may not be recoverable, the claimant must disclose its finances. A thinly funded special purpose enforcement vehicle cannot rely on being an SME or on access to justice to avoid giving security.

Key holding

Under Art 69(4) UPCA and R 158 RoP, the court must decide, on the facts and arguments the parties bring forward, whether the claimant's financial position raises a legitimate and real concern that a costs order may not be recoverable, or may not be enforceable without undue burden. The defendant requesting security bears the burden of substantiation and proof. Once it has presented its reasons and facts credibly, the claimant must challenge them in a substantiated way, because it normally holds the evidence of its own finances. The relative financial position of claimant and defendant is not as such a criterion under R 158 RoP, especially where a special purpose patent enforcement entity's limited funding is a deliberate business decision.

Questions decided

  1. Who bears the burden of substantiation and proof in a request for security for costs under R 158 RoP?
  2. When must the claimant disclose its own financial situation?
  3. Must the defendant prove that the claimant is or will be insolvent?
  4. Can a patent portfolio that may expire or be revoked count as sufficient security?
  5. Is the claimant's SME status relative to a large defendant relevant under R 158 RoP?
  6. Does a security order deny a funded enforcement vehicle access to justice?

Full summary

Read the full analyses for free — create a free account

With a free Academy account you read the full analysis of every Court of Appeal decision: the facts and procedure, the issues, the court’s reasoning and the practice points. Your name, an e-mail address and a password; no payment, and you can delete the account yourself at any time.

Create an account

At least 12 characters. A few words in a row make a strong password that’s easy to remember.

Already have an account?

In the same case

More on security for costs

Security for costs →

← All Court of Appeal summaries

Let’s talk

Tell us what you’re working on. We’ll get the right person on it and reply within one business day. The first chat is free.

Schedule a meeting