UPC Case Law
Audi AG v Network System Technologies LLC
Order of the UPC Court of Appeal of 18 September 2024, UPC CoA 264/2024
UPC Case Law by Pitch, edited by Bart Lieben · Published
TL;DR
The Court of Appeal rejected Audi's appeal against the Munich Local Division's refusal to dismiss three NST patent infringement actions at a preliminary stage. R 361 RoP (dismissal of an action that is manifestly bound to fail) is reserved for clear-cut cases. It cannot be used to test whether a Statement of claim is sufficiently substantiated, and a claimant may add arguments and evidence later despite the UPC's front-loaded system. The court also held that a UPC representative who withdraws an opt-out need not prove a power of attorney unless the court orders it.
Key holding
R 361 RoP must be reserved for clear-cut cases and should not lead to a full exchange of arguments and evidence. Whether a claim has been sufficiently argued, substantiated and proven is for the Court of First Instance to decide in the main proceedings. A Statement of claim that details infringement for one example embodiment and lists further embodiments said to infringe for essentially the same reasons is not manifestly lacking any foundation in law. Under R 285 RoP, an Art 48 UPCA representative need not produce a written mandate unless the court, on a challenge, orders it.
Questions decided
- May the Court of First Instance defer a jurisdictional preliminary objection to the main proceedings?
- Is an opt-out withdrawal by a UPC representative invalid without a filed power of attorney?
- Must an R 361 RoP request be decided on the Statement of claim alone?
- Can insufficient substantiation of the Statement of claim be raised under R 361 RoP?
- Does pleading one example embodiment plus a list of similar embodiments make an action manifestly unfounded?
- Does the Court of Appeal make a costs order in a non-final interlocutory appeal?
Full summary
Read the full analyses for free — create a free account
With a free Academy account you read the full analysis of every Court of Appeal decision: the facts and procedure, the issues, the court’s reasoning and the practice points. Your name, an e-mail address and a password; no payment, and you can delete the account yourself at any time.
In the same case
- Order · UPC CoA 265/2024
Volkswagen AG v Network System Technologies LLC
The Court of Appeal rejected Volkswagen's appeals against the Munich Local Division's refusal to dismiss NST's three infringement actions at an early stage.
- Order · UPC CoA 217/2024
Audi AG v Network System Technologies LLC
The Court of Appeal set aside three Munich Local Division orders and ordered Network System Technologies LLC (NST), a US patent enforcement entity, to provide security for costs of EUR 100,000, EUR 100,000 and EUR 300,000 to Audi AG. Security for costs is money or a guarantee a claimant must put up so the defendant can recover its costs if the claim fails.
- Order · UPC CoA 218/2024
Volkswagen AG v Network System Technologies LLC
The Court of Appeal set aside three Munich Local Division orders and required Network System Technologies LLC, a US patent enforcement company with two employees, to provide security for Volkswagen's costs totalling EUR 500,000.
- Order · UPC CoA 218/2024
Volkswagen AG v Network System Technologies LLC
The Court of Appeal confirmed that R 36 RoP, which lets a party ask to exchange further written pleadings, applies in appeal proceedings.
- Order · UPC CoA 217/2024
Audi AG v Network System Technologies LLC
The Court of Appeal rejected Audi's request to expedite its appeal against the refusal of security for costs, because Audi gave no specific reason why the response deadline or later time periods should be shortened.
- Order · UPC CoA 223/2024
Texas Instruments Incorporated and others v Network Systems Technologies LLC
The Court of Appeal rejected Texas Instruments' request to expedite its appeal against the Munich Local Division's refusal to order security for costs.
More on jurisdiction and competence
- Decision · UPC CoA 678/2025
Hurom Co., Ltd. v NUC Electronics Co., Ltd and others
The Court of Appeal upheld the Paris Local Division's revocation of Hurom's juicer patent EP 3 155 936 (as amended) for lack of inventive step, refused Hurom's new auxiliary requests filed only on appeal, and confirmed dismissal of all infringement claims, including those for Poland.
- Decision · UPC CoA 365/2025
Knaus Tabbert AG v Yellow Sphere Innovations GmbH and others
The Court of Appeal dismissed Knaus Tabbert's appeals and upheld the Düsseldorf Local Division's finding that its caravan frames infringe EP 3 356 109, which remains valid.
- Decision · UPC CoA 473/2025
Fujifilm Corporation v Kodak GmbH and others
The Court of Appeal reversed the Mannheim Local Division and held Fujifilm's lithographic printing plate patent (EP 3 476 616, as centrally limited) valid and infringed by Kodak's Sonora plates in Germany, granting an injunction, damages, information, recall and destruction.