Skip to content
pitch

UPC Case Law

Sumi Agro Limited and others v Syngenta Limited

Order of the UPC Court of Appeal of 19 December 2024, UPC CoA 523/2024

UPC Case Law by Pitch, edited by Bart Lieben · Published

TL;DR

The Court of Appeal excluded a further excerpt from a textbook that the appellant had already cited at first instance, because nothing had prevented it from filing those pages earlier. It admitted the respondent's new purchase and lab evidence on a possibly reformulated product, because the change of ingredient was disclosed only during the first-instance proceedings. Under R.222.2 RoP, a party that already had a source in hand will struggle to add more of it on appeal. Evidence prompted by the opponent's own late disclosures is likely to be admitted.

Key holding

Under R.222.2 RoP, a party that submitted pages from a publication at first instance has not justified that further pages from the same publication could not reasonably have been filed then, and the Court of Appeal may disregard them. Counter-evidence filed only on condition that the opponent's new evidence is admitted is disregarded once that evidence is excluded. Evidence on a possible new version of a contested product is admitted where the change of ingredient could not reasonably have been visible to the patentee and the party explains when and why it bought and analysed samples. Admission is decided on justification, relevance and the other party's position, without assessing the credibility of the evidence.

Questions decided

  1. Can further pages from a publication already filed at first instance be admitted on appeal under R.222.2 RoP?
  2. What happens to conditional counter-evidence when the evidence it answers is excluded?
  3. Is new evidence on a possibly reformulated contested product admissible on appeal?
  4. Does the Court of Appeal assess the credibility of new evidence when deciding whether to admit it?

Full summary

Read the full analyses for free — create a free account

With a free Academy account you read the full analysis of every Court of Appeal decision: the facts and procedure, the issues, the court’s reasoning and the practice points. Your name, an e-mail address and a password; no payment, and you can delete the account yourself at any time.

Create an account

At least 12 characters. A few words in a row make a strong password that’s easy to remember.

Already have an account?

In the same case

More on procedure

Procedure →

← All Court of Appeal summaries

Let’s talk

Tell us what you’re working on. We’ll get the right person on it and reply within one business day. The first chat is free.

Schedule a meeting