Skip to content
pitch

Academy · Series

The Unified Patent Court

Since 1 June 2023 a single court can rule on European patents for most of the EU at once. One action in the Unified Patent Court can stop an infringer in eighteen countries, and one counterclaim can revoke a patent for all of them. Founders who own or license patents, in-house counsel who get the letters and IP specialists who litigate: this is where to start.

Series The Unified Patent Court 10 parts The series, part by part ↓

Who this is for

  • Founders

    You own patents, or a competitor does. What a UPC action means for your product, your budget and your timing.

  • In-house counsel

    A summons, a preliminary injunction, an opt-out decision. The rules behind each step, with the article to check.

  • IP specialists

    How the Court of Appeal reads the Agreement and the Rules of Procedure, decision by decision.

Series · The Unified Patent Court

The series, part by part

Seven explainers, in reading order. Each takes ten minutes or less and cites the article of the Agreement (UPCA) or the rule of the Rules of Procedure (RoP) behind every statement; where a Court of Appeal decision shows the rule at work, it links that decision.

Guides are the open layer you can consult at any time; a series goes deeper, a curated path that takes you past the summaries.

Start with part 1 →

01 The basics

  1. 01 Explainer · Open The UPC and the unitary patent: structure, jurisdiction and opt-outOne court for patents across most of the EU, and one patent that covers them in a single step.
  2. 02 Explainer · Open Preliminary injunctions at the UPC: provisional measures explainedA preliminary injunction can stop an infringing product within weeks, across every UPC country.
  3. 03 Explainer · Open A UPC infringement action, step by stepThe UPC aims to decide an infringement case at first instance in about a year.
  4. 04 Explainer · Open Revocation actions and counterclaims at the UPCA patent can be knocked out at the UPC in one action for all the countries it covers.
  5. 05 Explainer · Open Costs, security for costs and the value of the dispute at the UPCAt the UPC the losing party pays a large share of the winner's legal costs, up to a ceiling that depends on what the case is worth.
  6. 06 Explainer · Open Languages of proceedings at the Unified Patent CourtThe UPC works in many languages, and the language of your case affects cost, speed and who can follow it.
  7. 07 Explainer · Open Appeals to the UPC Court of AppealEvery first-instance decision of the UPC can go to one Court of Appeal in Luxembourg, but orders follow stricter rules and much shorter deadlines.

02 Case law

  1. 08 Case law, TL;DR · Open Case law, TL;DREvery Court of Appeal decision that lays down a rule, in a few lines: the TL;DR, the key holding and the questions decided, by topic and by year.
  2. 09 Full analyses · Free account The full Court of Appeal analyses Facts and procedure, the issues, the reasoning, the significance and practice points of each decision, on the same pages once you sign in. Create a free account for The full Court of Appeal analyses →
  3. 10 Course · Free account UPC Case Law, the course The overview of UPC case law chapter by chapter, with the full text of every decision it cites. Create a free account for UPC Case Law, the course →

Case law, TL;DR

Every Court of Appeal decision and order that lays down a rule, newest first: the case, the parties and the rule in a few lines. The full analysis of each is free with an Academy account.

276 decisions

  1. · Order

    VALINEA ENERGIE SASU v TIRU

    TL;DRThe Court of Appeal upheld ex parte measures to preserve evidence and inspect a waste incineration furnace, ordered days before the furnace's first test run.

    Full analysis free with an account
  2. · Order

    MAGUIN v TIRU

    TL;DRThe Court of Appeal upheld an ex parte saisie (an order to preserve evidence and inspect premises granted without hearing the defendant) concerning a waste incineration furnace about to enter service.

    Full analysis free with an account
  3. · Order

    Chint New Energy Technology v JingAo Solar

    TL;DRThe Court of Appeal held inadmissible an appeal against a security for costs order made by a judge-rapporteur alone, because such an order is a case management order that must first be reviewed by the panel of the Court…

    Full analysis free with an account
  4. · Order

    Chint New Energy Technology and others v Jingao Solar

    TL;DRThe Court of Appeal ordered a Chinese patentee suing in the Hamburg Local Division to provide € 200,000 security for costs, overturning a first-instance refusal.

    Full analysis free with an account
  5. · Order

    Tiroler Rohre v SSAB Swedish Steel and others

    TL;DRWhen an action is withdrawn, the order allocating costs under R 265.2(c) RoP settles only who pays. The amount can still be fixed afterwards in separate cost proceedings under R 150 et seq. RoP.

    Full analysis free with an account
  6. · Order

    Network Systems Technologies v Qualcomm Incorporated and others

    TL;DRThe Court of Appeal upheld the Munich Local Division's order allowing exactly one of the claimant's US attorneys, and no more, to see the defendant's confidential information in three patent infringement actions.

    Full analysis free with an account
  7. · Decision

    Appellant (name not stated) v OrthoApnea and others

    TL;DRWhen an appeal is withdrawn, the Court of Appeal will only decide who bears the costs of the appeal. The amount must be claimed separately in cost proceedings under R 151 RoP, filed within one month of service of the…

    Full analysis free with an account
  8. · Order

    Easee and others v Visibly

    TL;DRThe Court of Appeal stayed both cross-appeals against a security-for-costs order for as long as the first-instance proceedings remain stayed.

    Full analysis free with an account
  9. · Order

    Ballinno v Kinexon Sports & Media and others

    TL;DRThe Court of Appeal upheld an order requiring the patentee Ballinno B.V. to provide € 56,000 security for costs in provisional-measures proceedings.

    Full analysis free with an account
  10. · Order

    Easee and others v Visibly

    TL;DRThe Court of Appeal suspended a Hamburg Local Division order that required the defendants in an infringement action to provide EUR 75,000 security for costs for their counterclaim for revocation.

    Full analysis free with an account
  11. · Order

    Sumi Agro and others v Syngenta

    TL;DRA UPC court fee counts as paid on the day the lodging party gives its bank the transfer order, not the day the money reaches the Court's account, provided the payment does arrive.

    Full analysis free with an account
  12. · Order

    AorticLab srl v Emboline

    TL;DRThe Court of Appeal held that Art 69(4) UPCA lets only a defendant request security for costs (a deposit or guarantee covering the other side's legal costs).

    Full analysis free with an account
  13. · Order

    ILME Elektrotechnische Handelsgesellschaft and others v PHOENIX CONTACT

    TL;DROnce the infringement action was withdrawn and the proceedings declared closed, ILME's pending appeal against the rejection of its preliminary objection served no purpose.

    Full analysis free with an account
  14. · Order

    Knaus Tabbert v Yellow Sphere Innovations and others

    TL;DRThe Court of Appeal rejected Knaus Tabbert's "Gegenvorstellung" (an informal objection asking the same court to reconsider its own decision) against the Court's earlier refusal to give its appeal suspensive effect.

    Full analysis free with an account
  15. · Decision

    Hanshow Technology and others v VusionGroup

    TL;DRThe one-month deadline in R 151.1 RoP for applying for a cost decision (the separate procedure that fixes the actual amount of recoverable costs) cannot be extended under R 9.3(a) RoP, even retroactively.

    Full analysis free with an account
  16. · Order

    Hybridgenerator v HGSystem and others

    TL;DRA request to impose periodic penalty payments under R 354.4 RoP must be decided by a panel of the Court of First Instance, not by a single judge.

    Full analysis free with an account
  17. · Order

    XSYS Germany and others v Esko-Graphics Imaging

    TL;DRThe Court of Appeal held that the UPC has competence over a patent infringement action covering acts committed before the UPC Agreement entered into force on 1 June 2023.

    Full analysis free with an account
  18. · Order

    Belkin and others v Koninklijke Philips

    TL;DRThe Court of Appeal held that UPC penalty payments for breaching a court order are punitive as well as coercive, so they remain payable even after the defendant has belatedly complied.

    Full analysis free with an account
  19. · Order

    Centripetal v Palo Alto Networks

    TL;DRThe Court of Appeal revoked the Mannheim Local Division's refusal to order preservation of evidence and inspection against Palo Alto Networks, Inc.

    Full analysis free with an account
  20. · Decision

    President and Fellows of Harvard College v NanoString Technologies Europe

    TL;DRA revocation claimant who won at first instance may withdraw its action during the appeal under R 265.1 RoP. When the proceedings close, the first-instance decision revoking the patent becomes ineffective.

    Full analysis free with an account
  21. · Order

    President and Fellows of Harvard College v NanoString Technologies Europe

    TL;DRBefore the Court of Appeal, the written procedure closes once the statement of response has been lodged and its time limit under R 235 RoP has expired, unless there is a cross-appeal.

    Full analysis free with an account
  22. · Order

    STRABAG Infrastructure & Safety Solutions v SWARCO FUTURIT Verkehrssignalsysteme

    TL;DRThe Court of Appeal refused an intervener's request for suspensive effect (the first-instance decision is put on hold pending the appeal) of an infringement decision of the Vienna Local Division.

    Full analysis free with an account
  23. · Order

    Knaus Tabbert v Yellow Sphere Innovations and others

    TL;DRThe Court of Appeal refused to give suspensive effect to Knaus Tabbert's appeal against a Düsseldorf infringement decision ordering recall and destruction of caravans, and refused to make enforcement conditional on…

    Full analysis free with an account
  24. · Order

    Hisense Gorenje Germany and others v Corning Incorporated

    TL;DRThe Court of Appeal refused to review the Mannheim Local Division's refusal to split one infringement action against three competing groups of TV makers (Hisense, TCL and LG) into separate proceedings.

    Full analysis free with an account

All Court of Appeal summaries, by topic The UPC Case Law course: Bart Lieben’s overview of UPC case law, chapter by chapter, with every decision and order in full.

Read the full analyses for free — create a free account

With a free Academy account you read the full analysis of every Court of Appeal decision: the facts and procedure, the issues, the court’s reasoning and the practice points. Your name, an e-mail address and a password; no payment, and you can delete the account yourself at any time.

Create a free accountAlready have an account? Sign in

Let’s talk

Tell us what you’re working on. We’ll get the right person on it and reply within one business day. The first chat is free.

Schedule a meeting